‏הצגת רשומות עם תוויות standardized tests. הצג את כל הרשומות
‏הצגת רשומות עם תוויות standardized tests. הצג את כל הרשומות

יום שני, 22 בפברואר 2016

Testing, testing

Although it's not officially part of my job, occasionally I find myself helping to supervise or correct tests at school. It can be quite a humbling experience, discovering that my English is less than perfect according to the Ministry of Education.

Last week I corrected a sixth grade test. Had I been taking the test myself, I would have lost at least 6 points because I thought that the best title for the story was not the one given in the answer key. I may have been angry rather than dissappointed when I couldn't go to a birthday party, or thought that I was supposed to decorate rather than clean my room, and I would have lost a few more points. I'm creative and imaginative by nature but I know that the people who write these tests aren't, so I would have known better than to say that I died in 1996 or that I was sad because my dog argued, which shows that I do have some test-taking skills.

And test-taking skills are exactly what you need to pass a standardized test. That's why in order to prepare for these tests we stop teaching English and just practice doing old tests. They also have very strict guidelines as to how they should be graded, so that under no circumstances will a child be given extra points for being smarter than the person who wrote the test. Points are given for finding the write answer, nothing extra for a perfectly written complete sentence which proves that the student actually understands the question and answer. Of course, there are enough trick questions to make sure that no one can get everything right. And what about all of the students who didn't know what to do when the instructions said "Answer the following question." followed by a sentence and then another instruction - "Copy a word from the text that shows this". Shouldn't they get some credit for noticing that there wasn't a question? But the person who wrote the test also wrote the guidelines for correcting it and obviously didn't notice the mistake. 

This was all in the last two weeks. But I still remember one of the moments years ago when I realized that I would never survive as a formal teacher. I was surpervising a test in elementary school and the children had to read a passage and then mark sentences true or false. About half of the students said that they couldn't tell from the story if one of the sentences was true or false. I read the story and the sentence and realized that they were correct, the answer wasn't there, so I told them to write next to it that they couldn't tell. Afterwards I told the class teacher that I thought there was a mistake in the test and she told me no, everyone knows that if you can't find the answer in the text then the answer is false. I told her what I had told the students and she said that since I told them that she would accept it. I couldn't accept that. What was she testing? If they said that the information wasn't in the text and it wasn't, they obviously understood both the text and the sentence. What is the point of taking off points for not knowing the rule that "don't know = false"? 

Teachers, including those like me who teach informally, are told that before we prepare a lesson we should know what it is we want the students to learn. Test preparers need to start asking themselves the same question - What is it that they are testing?

יום שלישי, 26 בינואר 2016

The Emperor's New Standards

Our story begins in the 20th century.

One day, the emperor asked for new standards. "Who can bring me standards which will tell me how much students learn, how much they know and how well the teachers are doing their job?" he asked. Experts from across the kingdom brought him all kinds of tests and recommended assigning papers and projects. The emperor was confused. "How will we know if every teacher is using the same criteria? Can we trust the judgment of teachers and principals? How will we compare different schools?"

One day a wise man arrived with a PhD in education and a stack of research. He offered the emperor a standardized test. "With this test you can check every student according to the same criteria, compare them and find out where the good and bad teachers are" he said. The emperor looked at the test and said "But I don't see any measure of knowledge or understanding." The wise man explained that these tests were written by experts in education following many years of research. The emperor, who didn't want to appear ignorant, issued a new order. From now on all students and schools will be measured according to these tests. Principals instructed teachers that they must meet the standards set by the emperor. All educators studied the tests thoroughly in order to find out exactly what students needed to know. Everyone began to prepare for the big day. They memorized the necessary information, learned to read and follow instructions and practiced every type of question so that they would know how to answer each and every one properly.

The day arrived. The emperor sent inspectors to deliver the tests to every school in the kingdom. All of the students sat quietly, the teachers stood at attention, everyone knew exactly what they were expected to do. Suddenly one child got up and shouted "This test is useless!" The principal gave the teacher a stern look, and the teacher quickly quieted the child. But the child stood up again. "This test is useless!" he shouted again, "I understand all the material but some of these questions make no sense!" A child from another school shouted, "What's the problem? We don't need to study, we just need to figure out the system."  The teachers and principals looked again at the tests. They realized that the children were right. One teacher called out "We stopped all relevant and meaningful learning to prepare for these tests!" That teacher was immediately sent to an alternative school, and no one else dared to oppose the emperor.

The kingdom continues to hold standardized tests every year.